Random Thought - LOTR

If Tolkien were resurrected and plonked down in front of all 3 extended DVDs, on a big screen, with surround sound, of the Lord of the Rings books he wrote - would he approve of what they did with it?  Would he say, "hey, that's just the way I imagined Orcs!"?  Or would he be upset that it didn't excatly follow the book, and added in bits that really aren't there?  Would he appreciate the artistic weaving of his story into a visual medium?  Would he have some pretty cool suggestions on how it could be done differently?
 
I hope Heaven has the DVDs in stock and a really good playback system....